|
Supportive
Environment
The
Convention of the Rights of the Child (CRC) which Bhutan ratified in 1990 provides
the international legal framework for children's rights, including access to
adequate health services, clean drinking water, protection from malnutrition,
and generally the highest standards of life attainable. These rights of the
child are guaranteed by the RGoB and a Child's
Rights Task Force exists to oversee, advance and protect the rights and
welfare of children in the country.
Besides
primary health care, the RGoB has in place several
programmes and projects in place which are specifically directed at improving
child health such as the EPI, Maternal & Child Health, Nutrition, ARI and diarrhoeal disease programmes. These
essential child health care services, including supply of medicines and
vaccines, are provided free of cost. Services are to be further intensified
and coverage levels expanded under the Ninth Five Year Plan.
The
implementation of child health programmes are carried out by the Public
Health Division which has adopted the Integrated 'Management of Childhood
Illness (IMCI) strategy to
manage child illnesses. Other positive initiatives that have been undertaken
to promote better childcare practices are the development of a national
policy on breast-feeding, the designation of baby-friendly hospitals, and the
expansion of existing Maternal and Child Health (MCH)
facilities including "Well Child" clinics.
Priorities for Development
Assistance
Increasing access to and improving
the quality of child care services
Improving institutional &
management capacities at national & local levels
Supporting ARI
and Diarrhoea management programmes
Supporting the Health Trust Fund
for the purchase of vaccines and drugs
Enhancing awareness and education
in communities
Monitoring and Evaluation Environment
|
Elements of Monitoring
|
Assessment
|
|
Data gathering capacities
|
Fair
|
|
Quality of recent information
|
Fair
|
|
Statistical tracking capacities
|
Weak
|
|
Statistical analysis capacities
|
Weak
|
|
Capacity to incorporate statistical analysis into policy, planning,
and
resource allocation mechanisms
|
Fair
|
|
Monitoring and evaluation
mechanisms
|
Fair
|
GOAL 5: IMPROVE MATERNAL HEALTH
|
TARGET 6
|
Reduce by three
quarters, between 1990 and 2015, the maternal mortality ratio
|
|
Indicator
|
1990
|
2000
|
|
Will
Goal be met by 2015?
|
|
Maternal mortality
Ratio per 100,000 live births
|
560
|
255
|
140
|
Probably
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Status
and Trends
The
maternal mortality rate (MMR)
for 2000 was estimated at 255 per 100,000 live births, a dramatic reduction by over half from the high figure of 560 per 100,000 in 1990.
Extrapolating this trend and based on the continuation of appropriate
interventions, the MDG target of
reducing maternal mortality ratio by three-quarters is likely to be achieved
by 2015.
The
qualitative improvements in and the increased accessibility to reproductive
health services, and related information and awareness thereof, have been
identified as the reasons for the steep reductions in the MMR. More specifically, the declines in maternal
mortality rates were related to the advocacy and implementation of safe
motherhood and pregnancy/ delivery practices, ante and post natal clinical
examinations, immunization against tetanus, and the widespread distribution
of iron and folic acid tablets to reduce anaemia in pregnant women. The
distribution of "safe-home delivery kits" was also tried on a
pilot basis and replicated nationally from 1998 onwards to help facilitate
safe deliveries.
Not
withstanding the progress, MMR
levels can be reduced even further. Maternal mortality and pregnancy/labour
complications have been linked to mother's anaemia and nutritional
deficiencies, haemorrhage, puerperal sepsis, malaria, obstructed labour
complications, retained placenta, toxaemia, unsafe abortions, malaria and
associated hypertensive diseases. Several of these conditional causes of
maternal mortality are thought to be easily preventable. Socially, maternal
mortality has also been linked to teenage pregnancies and early motherhood
which increase the likelihood of high risk pregnancies and deliveries.
The
percentage of deliveries attended by skilled health personnel has increased
from 15 percent in 1994 to 24 percent in 2000 to 52 in 2005.

Challenges
While
maternal mortality rates can be reduced substantially through the presence of
skilled health personnel during deliveries, there is a severe constraint due
to the dire shortage of health-trained manpower resources and the lack of
adequate equipment and facilities in the country. The situation is further
compounded by lack of accessibility to health units particularly in the more
remote areas.
An
important challenge in reducing maternal mortality will depend to a great
extent on the RGoB's ability to expand and further
strengthen Emergency Obstetric Care (EmOC)
facilities and services and their effective utilization by communities. While
such initiatives started in 2000 with a significant increase in the number of
basic and comprehensive EmOC facilities. There is a
need to further strengthen and expand these services, particularly in the
context of the widely dispersed and scattered population settlements and
difficult terrain.
Some of
the other challenges that the country faces in improving maternal health care
and reducing MMR are related to
cultural and awareness barriers that inhibit widespread contraceptive usage,
early motherhood, increasing teenage pregnancies, unsafe illegal abortions,
and the lack of information among Bhutanese women on reproductive health and
safe motherhood.
Supportive Environment
There is
high level and strong political commitment to further reduce the MMR and improve maternal and reproductive health
services. Her Majesty Ashi Sangay
Choden Wangchuck, in her
role as Goodwill ambassador of the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA),
has played a high profile advocacy role in highlighting important
reproductive health issues of safe motherhood practices, adolescent health
and teenage pregnancies, and family planning.
The
Bhutan Vision 2020 document emphasizes the need to reduce maternal mortality
and bring it at par with the average of all developing countries by 2007. The
Ninth Five Year Plan document also highlights the fact that MMRs are still unacceptably high despite significant
achievements, and identifies related issues such as safe pregnancy and
motherhood, teenage pregnancies and family planning, as key areas deserving
renewed focus.
At the
programme level, under a National Plan of Action formulated in 1997, several
activities support the goal of improving maternal health and reducing MMR. Among the most important of these is the
Maternal and Child Health (MCH)
programme with the specific objective to contribute to the reduction of MMR. The Safe Motherhood and Reproductive Health
programme also seeks to reduce MMRs through
activities focused on making health services and facilities more "woman
friendly", increasing access to antenatal and postnatal care, and
increasing births attended by skilled attendants.
Priorities for Development
Assistance
Improving access to and quality of
Reproductive Health Services, particularly antenatal & postnatal care
Strengthening capacity building,
particularly for health service providers in rural areas Increasing presence
of skilled health personnel during deliveries
Promoting community participation,
education & awareness on safe motherhood & reproductive health issues
Enhancing decentralised, multi-sectoral & integrated approaches
Strengthening EmOC
Services
Improving advocacy &
monitoring
Monitoring and Evaluation
Environment
|
Data gathering
capacities
|
Fair
|
|
Quality of recent
information
|
Weak
|
|
Statistical
tracking capacities
|
Fair
|
|
Statistical
analysis capacities
|
Weak
|
|
Capacity to
incorporate statistical
analysis into policy, planning and
resource
allocation mechanisms
|
Fair
|
|
Monitoring and
evaluation
mechanisms
|
Weak
|
GOAL 6: COMBAT HIV, MALARIA AND
OTHER DISEASES
|
TARGET 7
|
Have halted by 2015
and begun to reverse the spread of HIV/AIDS
|
|
|
Indicator
|
1990
|
2000
|
|
Will
Goal be met by 2015?
|
|
HIV cases detected
|
0
|
38
|
-
|
Insufficient Data
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Status
and Trends
The first
two HIV cases in Bhutan
were reported in 1993. By 2002, 38 individuals had been identified as HIV
positive, with thirteen cases detected in 2002 alone. The prevalence was
highest for the age groups between 20 and 34, all of them urban cases. In all
but one case, the identified HIV patients had apparently contracted the
infection through sex, though none were reportedly transmitted through
homosexual activity. From among these cases, seven have died so far.
In view
of the rising trend of HIV infection, even as the total numbers of HIV cases
remain small; this has attracted wide public attention. It is seen as a
potentially major public health concern, particularly in the context of the
relatively common incidence of Sexually Transmitted Diseases (STDs), the
emergence of sex workers in border towns and the high prevalence of the
HIV/AIDS in neighbouring countries.
The
Health Division already had in place a National STD/AIDS
programme in 1988, well before the first reported incidences of the disease.
In 1990, a three-year Medium Term Plan was formulated that evolved into the
Strategic Medium Term Plan II of 1995 to continue addressing the prevention
of sexual transmission of HIV.
The
programme activities so far have essentially focused on preventive and
advocacy measures such as informing, counselling and educating vulnerable
groups, including youths and sex workers; promoting widespread condom usage
and safe sex; training health care workers and monitoring the situation
through sentinel surveillance. It is planned that in addition to making
condoms widely available, voluntary counselling and testing units and HIV
surveillance systems are to be established by the end of the Ninth Five Year
Plan in all districts, though this is likely to be constrained by the
availability of trained counsellors.
Challenges
As the
prevalence of HIV/AIDS in the country is still relatively low, the challenges
of dealing with it relate more to monitoring and surveillance, preventive and
Information Education and Communication (IEC) aspects and developing coping
strategies in the eventuality of a rise in the spread of the disease.
The
potential danger of the disease spreading in the country is a real threat as
the country is adjacent to areas in the region that have high HIV/AIDS
prevalence. The high mobility of people and open cross border movements
therefore pose significant and real risks. Additionally, the risks of the
spread of HIV infection are heightened by the common prevalence of sexually
transmitted diseases and low condom usage. Further, there is a disconcerting
increase of sex workers in border towns. Developing bilateral cooperative
strategies and coordination to monitor and contain the spread of HIV/AIDS
will therefore prove a significant challenge.
As the experience of many countries indicates, youth
are a particularly vulnerable group with high HIV/AIDS prevalence. With over
51 percent of the country's population being under 20, the issue has a
potential significance. The country is faced with the important and
challenging task to sensitize, inform and educate the youth in the country
about the dangers of HIV/ AIDS, and on related issues of safe sex, condom
usage, and dangers of drug abuse. In conjunction with the wide dissemination
of information and education, an even more important challenge is to ensure
that these activities effectively translate into appropriate behavioural
change among and utilized by the targeted vulnerable groups. This could
comprise the development of youth friendly facilities to promote effective
utilization of available sexual health services, particularly condom usage by
youths.
Supportive Environment
Bhutan as a member of South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation
(SAARC), along with the other South Asian countries, issued a strong
declaration at the 111" SAARC Summit, acknowledging the
debilitating and widespread impact of HIV/AIDS and other transmittable
diseases and the imperative to evolve a regional strategy to combat these
diseases.
Nationally, the programme enjoys high political support and
commitment. Her Majesty the Queen, Ashi Sangay Choden Wangchuck, in her role as the UNFPA Goodwill Ambassador
has been campaigning strongly about the control of STDs and HIV/AIDS across
all districts. The National Assembly also discussed the issue of HIV/AIDS in
2001 and subsequently passed a resolution to further step up preventive
measures and information and awareness to prevent and minimize the impact of
the disease. Such high-level advocacy initiatives have had a strong impact.
Efforts have been made to include HIV/AIDS awareness into the curricula of
schools and teacher training institutes.
The various strategies and activities to combat the
disease are implemented through the National STDs/ AIDS Control Programme
under the Department of Health. A National AIDS Committee was established in
1994 and is backstopped by a National AIDS Technical Committee. At the
district levels, Multi-Sectoral Task Force
Committees and Working Committees have been established in all districts to
take preventive measures and create awareness, while being prepared to deal
with any outbreak of the disease.
While Bhutan
does not presently have an independent Policy Directive for HIV/AIDS
prevention, the RGoB broadly adheres to the WHO
recommendations articulated in its Global AIDS Strategy document. A Protocol
for HIV sentinel surveillance exists, but it is acknowledged to require
improvements in order to serve effectively as a tool to contain the spread of
HIV.
Priorities
for Development Assistance
Supporting AIDS programme
management
Intensifying prevention activities
& measures, particularly at local levels through awareness raising
Strengthening effective monitoring
& sentinel surveillance systems
Capacity building at national
& local levels Strengthening counselling and care facilities
Integrating HIV/AIDS aspects into
national health systems
Monitoring
and Evaluation Environment
|
Elements Of Monitoring
|
Assessment
|
|
Data gathering capacities
|
Fair
|
|
Quality of recent information
|
Fair
|
|
Statistical tracking capacities
|
Weak
|
|
Statistical analysis capacities
|
Weak
|
|
Capacity to incorporate statistical analysis into policy, planning
and resource allocation mechanisms
|
Fair
|
|
Monitoring and evaluation Mechanisms
|
Fair
|
|
TARGET 8
|
Have halted by 2015 and begun to reverse
the incidence of Malaria and other diseases
|
|
Indicators
|
1990
|
2000
|
2015
|
Will
Goal be met by 2015 ?
|
|
Number of reported malaria cases
|
9,497
|
5,935
|
-
|
Probably
|
|
Number of reported tuberculosis cases
|
4,232
|
1,140
|
-
|
Probably
|
Status
and Trends
Malaria
Malaria has long been a major public health problem
for Bhutan,
and is endemic to five districts in the subtropical regions of southern Bhutan and
some of the riverine valleys. Together, the two
southern districts of Sarpang and Samdrup Jongkhar account for
around 75 percent of all reported malaria cases in Bhutan.
Malaria incidence in the country during the 1990s showed a broad
downward trend, though it is sporadic and uneven, indicating periods of small
malarial outbreaks and/or resurgences. Reported positive clinical malaria
over the decade grew from 22,126 positive cases in 1991 to a high of 38,901
in 1994, but then declined steeply to 6,995 in 1998. In 1999 and 2000,
malarial cases were at 12,591 and 5,935 respectively (Annual Health Bulletin, 2001). Malaria related
mortality/morbidity also broadly follows the caseload trend of overall
decline, including the slight resurgence in 1999. While there were 62 malaria
caused deaths in 1993, there were only 15 malaria related deaths in 2000. The
positive development of a marked reduction in malaria cases between 1995 and
2000 (except for an upsurge in 1999) has largely been attributed to the
change in insecticides from DDT to synthetic Pyrethroid.
Of the two varieties of malaria prevalent in the
country, P.vivaxand Pfalciparum, there has been a steady overall increase of the latter cases in
the last few years from 31.5 percent in 1995 to 53 percent in 2001. The
fatality of this most severe form of malaria is well documented in many
countries. Additionally, this has serious implications for the future control
of malaria, as the Pfalicparumparasite is well known to be
resistant to anti-malarial drugs such as Chloroquine
and SP.
The MDG
target of arresting the spread of malaria appears to be achievable. Reversing
it, however, may be more difficult in light of the significant fluctuations
and resurgences that have occurred, not only in the 1990s, but also
consistently through the last three decades. The disease therefore continues
to remain a major public health concern with more than half of the county's
total population exposed to the risk of infection. The health authorities in
the country are also highly doubtful that the disease can ever be eradicated
totally, and hence the appropriate change in strategy to containment and
control rather than eradication.
Tuberculosis
The number of reported tuberculosis (TB) cases in the country declined
significantly and consistently from 4,323 cases in 1990 to 1,140 in 2000. The
most noticeable shift appears to have occurred between 1993 and 1994 after
which detected cases dropped from over 4,000 to less than 2000 thereafter. TB
related mortality rates for the decade, however, were erratic and fluctuated
between 23 and 62 deaths a year with no discernible trend either way.
On average, 58 percent of TB patients are in the age group between 15 and 44
years. Most of the TB cases in the country are of the pulmonary kind, making
up around 75 percent of all cases. A perceptible trend is the decline in
pulmonary TB while cases of extra pulmonary TB have actually seen a slight
increase from 1995 to 2000.
In line with the revised global TB control strategy,
DOTS (Directly Observed Treatment
Short-Course) was adopted throughout the country in 1997. This has had a
noticeable impact on cure rates, which now stand at over 85 percent, a highly
positive trend. Improving access to DOTS and enhancing its utilization is now
a significant priority for the RGoB. The Cohort
Reporting System was introduced in 2000, which is expected to improve
reporting quality and enhance information and data reliability.
The considerable reduction of cases for TB strongly
indicates that part of the MDG
target of halting the incidence of the disease has been achieved and the
process of reversing the trend has already started and is likely be achieved
by 2015.
Challenges
Tackling malaria in Bhutan
is constrained to an extent as malarial areas are for the most part in the
southern border areas. Conducting prevention and control related activities
such as the spraying of breeding sites require concerted joint coordination
and efforts. The free movement of people along the border compounds the
difficulties and helps to spread the disease. Sporadic cases are also
regularly detected in the non-malarial regions of the mountainous North and
central zones, caused through the increasing mobility and migration of
people.
Some of the other constraints and challenges faced in battling malaria
relate to an increasing tolerance and resistance to insecticides and drugs by
mosquitoes; shortage of skilled technicians and researchers; lack of
resources and adequately equipped health infrastructures; weak inter-sectoral collaboration and programme management at local
levels; and the inaccessibility of large tracts of malaria endemic areas due
to dense forests.
Progress towards the MDG target of halting and reversing the trend of
malarial incidence in the country will also be largely affected by the
availability of financial resources related to the procurement of
insecticides and treatment drugs, which form a major expenditure for the
programme.
Supportive Environment
The National Malaria Eradication Programme (later
renamed as the National Malaria Control Programme, or NMCP) was launched in
1964 and has since spearheaded the various activities to fight the spread of
malaria in Bhutan,
including conducting research on drug sensitivity and entomological aspects.
The programme has gone through various stages of evolution from a vertical
strategy to a partial integration to a full fledged integration into the
general health care delivery system. Control strategies likewise have changed
from Indoor Residual Spraying (IRS)
with DDT to IRS with synthetic Pyrethroid, and then to the present day Insecticide
Treated Bed Net and bioenvironmental control approaches. The programme
envisages the need to further strengthen the facilities, related human
resources and other capacities at the, various malaria health centres.
At the district level in
malaria endemic areas, the health authorities have begun forming Rapid
Response Teams to deal with any potential outbreaks of malaria.
Many of the above programme activities and costs for
procurement of insecticides and treatment drugs have been supported actively
by a bilateral donor. While Bhutan
has broadly followed the strategic intervention guidelines of the global Roll
Back Malaria (RBM) strategy, it is not comprehensively engaged in the RBM
initiative and process as Bhutan
in not included among the RBM areas in the region.
Priorities for Development
Assistance
Procuring insecticides & treatment
drugs
Strengthening of programme management and capacity development
for implementation & research
Enhancing Insecticide Treated Bed Net
coverage
Supporting intensification of malaria
awareness campaigns and greater community participation ,
Continuing drugs sensitivity and
insecticide susceptibility research
Enhancing access to DOTS (Directly
Observed
Treatment Short-Course)
Monitoring
and Evaluation Environment
|
Data
gathering capacities
|
Fair
|
|
Quality
of recent information
|
Fair
|
|
Statistical
tracking capacities
|
Weak
|
|
Statistical
analysis capacities
|
Weak
|
|
Capacity
to incorporate statistical analysis into policy, planning and resource
allocation mechanisms
|
Fair
|
|
Monitoring
and evaluation mechanisms
|
Fair
|
GOAL 7: ENSURE ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY
|
TARGET 9
|
Integrate the principles of sustainable development
into country policies and programmes and reverse loss of environmental
resources
|
|
Indicators
|
1990
|
2000
|
2015
|
Will
Goal be met by 2015 ?
|
|
|
Proportion of land area covered by forest
|
73%
|
73%
|
-
|
Probably
|
|
|
Proportion of land protected
through soil, moisture, water and forest conservation to protect
biological diversity
|
23%
|
26%"
|
-
|
Probably
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Status and Trends
Bhutan
has a rich natural endowment with an extremely abundant forest cover of 73
percent and with 26 percent of its territory established as protected areas
to conserve its rich biodiversity. Additional areas constituting 9 of the
total land area have also been designated as biological corridors that
connect the protected areas.
Environmental
conservation has always enjoyed a high priority in the RGoB's
vision of holistic development and the cause continues to be an important and
integral consideration in the development agenda. The holistic concept and
principles of sustainable development closely match the Bhutanese development
philosophy and are integrated into the national policies and programmes. The
sensitivity towards and prioritisation of environmental conservation is also
reflected in the numerous legislations adopted and in the institutional strengthening
and capacity building activities during the 1990s.
The
National Environment Commission (NEC), formed in 1990, formulated a National
Environment Strategy for the country in 1998, known as the Middle Path. This
build-up of the institutional and policy framework was accompanied by the
passage of critical environmental legislation. The most notable of these
relate to the adoption of the Environmental Assessment Act 2000, the Forest and Nature Conservation Act 1995, the Mines and
Minerals Act 1995, and the National Plant Quarantine Act 1993.
The
RGoB is also in the process of formulating an
important piece of legislation, the National Environment Protection Act
(NEPA), which is likely to be enacted and enforced within the Ninth Five Year
Plan period. At the international level, Bhutan is a signatory to the
Convention on Biological Diversity and the UN Framework Convention for
Climate Change.
Challenges
While
Bhutan's
environmental track record has been enviable, there are certain challenges
emerging that could seriously compromise the future state of the environment.
Among
the key challenges confronting the goal of ensuring environmental
sustainability is the rapid population growth that Bhutan is experiencing. While the
growth level has come down from 3.1 percent, the present growth rate of 2.5
percent still poses a serious threat to the country's environmental
resources.
With
increasing pressures on grazing land, agriculture, and forest resources, the
protection of forest lands and conservation of biological diversity are
expected to become ever more difficult. Bhutan's fuel wood consumption
per capita is particularly high. Overgrazing by domestic livestock has
further been identified as a serious environmental threat with great
potential to impact forest regeneration and effect changes in natural
vegetation. Recently, air and water pollution near industrialised and urban
areas have been of concern.
The
modernization and economic development of the country invariably require the
establishment of extensive road infrastructure. This is an important priority
for the RGoB and regarded as vital for alleviating
rural poverty. Given the high vulnerability and fragility of mountain
eco-systems and the lack of advanced construction techniques and expertise,
the building of an extensive network of mountain highways and feeder roads in
an environment-friendly manner will prove to be a major challenge. This would
similarly apply to urban and development associated infrastructure building.
Incorporating
Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and relevant environmental friendly
practices in development and industrial projects results in increased
associated investment and maintenance costs. The sacrifices of foregoing
immediate economic gains to further protect natural resources, and the costs
for maintaining and managing environmental conservation, collectively create
an enormous burden on scarce resources. Viewed within the context of
declining international donor assistance for core environmental management
activities, the financial implications form a key challenge and debilitating
constraint, which could have severe implications for the future state of the
environment.
There
are also several capacity related constraints pertaining to the management,
monitoring and evaluation of the state of the environment such as the:
lack of a nationwide inventory of
ecosystems;
paucity of environmental data
& research • information;
absence of a set of appropriate
environmental indicators; and
shortage of qualified &
trained environmental practitioners.
Supportive
Environment
There is full and strong
national support for ensuring environment sustainability in the country. This
is best exemplified by the mandate of the National Assembly and the pledged
commitment of the Royal Government to maintain at least 60 percent of the
country under forest cover in perpetuity. The development vision of the
country as articulated .in the Bhutan Vision 2020 document further
places a very high accord to the principles of environmental conservation and
sustainable development.
The various policy, institutional, legislative and
regulatory developments already outlined in the status and situational
context, serve as the important supportive framework for achieving the MDG target. Additionally, the NEC introduced
mandatory EIAs for all large-scale projects and is
in the process of applying this requirement for all physical infrastructure
projects, to be monitored by the EIA unit in the Commission. EIAs are therefore being effectively integrated into the
development planning and the environmental management process. Watershed
management has also been identified as an important tool through which
environmental conservation can be furthered. The Wang Watershed Management
Project is already under implementation and there are plans to undertake
similar projects for the four other major watersheds. Processes to develop a
national watershed management strategy are also underway.
Bhutan Trust Fund
for Environmental Conservation
The Bhutan Trust Fund for Environmental Conservation (BTF), the
world's first environmental trust fund, was launched in 1991 with the intent
to help the country sustain its environmental conservation activities. The
trust fund, with an endowment of US$ 35 million, contributed by a consortium
of donors and the RGoB, finances from its income
various projects and activities in:
- environmental & conservation education
- integrated conservation and development
- biodiversity inventory & information
- systems
- planning & management of protected
areas
- strengthening national environmental
institutions
The BTF has laid the foundation for an effective long-term and
sustainable conservation programme in Bhutan, and also serves as a
global model that is being replicated elsewhere.
The RGoB developed some innovative funding mechanisms such as
the Bhutan Trust Fund for Environmental Conservation (BTF) (see box above)
and the unique multi-partnership of countries under the Sustainable
Development Agreement, which have greatly enhanced the financial and
long-term sustainability of environmental conservation activities.
Priorities
for Development Assistance
Strengthening
capacities in information systems and research; institutional
development & popular participation; policies & legislation;
training & education; and monitoring and evaluation & enforcement at
all levels
Strengthening institutional
capacities to undertake EIAs
Improving environment databases
and mitigation options for all sectors towards implementing effective and
appropriate responses to climate change
Formulating & implementing the
National Environment Action Plan to implement recommendations of the National
Environment Strategy
Preparing and implementing
watershed
Management plans
Developing a nationwide inventory
of eco-systems Supporting the BTF
Participating at international
conferences and implementing activities and enforcing the provisions of these
conventions
Monitoring and Evaluation Environment
|
Elements Of Monitoring
|
Assessment
|
|
Data gathering capacities
|
Weak
|
|
Quality of recent information
|
Weak
|
|
Statistical tracking capacities
|
Weak
|
|
Statistical analysis capacities
|
Fair
|
|
Capacity to incorporate statistical analysis into policy, planning
and resource allocation mechanisms
|
Weak
|
|
Monitoring and evaluation
mechanisms
|
Fair
|
|
TARGET 10
|
Halve, by 2015 the
proportion of people without sustainable access to safe drinking water and
basic sanitation
|
|
Indicators
|
1990
|
2000
|
2015
|
Will Goal be met by 2015 ?
|
|
Percentage of population without access to safe drinking water sources
|
55%
|
22%
|
27%
|
Achieved
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Status and Trends
78
percent of Bhutan's
population had access to safe drinking water in 2000 as compared to 45
percent in 1990. In the urban areas, access to safe drinking water as of 2000
is at 97.5 percent, while in the rural areas it is estimated to be around 75
percent. However, while coverage in rural areas has increased significantly,
many people still have to walk long distances to fetch water from streams and
springs, thus limiting water use.
The Rural Water Supply and Sanitation (RWSS)
Programme was initiated in 1974 to improve the health of the rural population
by reducing the incidence of water-borne and related diseases. Under the
programme, 2,300 water supply schemes, mostly of the gravity fed type, have
been constructed to provide safe drinking water to about three fourths of the
rural population. The notable improvements in the health standards of people
in rural areas can be attributed, to a certain extent, to this programme,
which has greatly reduced water and sanitation related diseases.
The RGoB's target is that
by the end of the Ninth Five Year Plan in 2007, 100 percent of the population
will enjoy access to safe drinking water. This will require the annual
construction of 130 new schemes, in addition to rehabilitating and maintaining
numerous old schemes.
The
six major towns in the country have been provided with proper and modern
water supply schemes, and the issues are more related to qualitative and
quantitative supplies of water than access. In order to enhance conservation
and the awareness of the cost and value of water supplies, nominal charges
were levied to urban water consumers after the completion of the urban water
supply schemes.
As
the overall percentage of people without access to safe drinking water
decreased from 55 percent in 1990 to 22 percent in 2000, the MDG target has already been achieved.
Challenges
Increasing
and maintaining access to safe drinking water is a more pressing issue in
rural than in urban areas. A critical challenge in maintaining and further
enhancing safe and improved water coverage to rural populations will depend
greatly on the maintenance and rehabilitation of older water supply schemes.
It is estimated that around 800, or roughly one third of existing schemes,
must be repaired to avoid contamination and total dilapidation of the
structures. Meeting the goal of attaining complete safe water coverage will
not only require the annual construction of many more new schemes, but the
rehabilitation of at least 150 older schemes every year until the end of the
Ninth Five Year Plan.
There
is a need to identify and use alternative technologies for areas where water
sources are scarce, and to develop simple treatment facilities that can be
operated and maintained by communities without clean water sources. Given the
significant costs and community inputs required for maintaining and repairing
rural water supply schemes, the durability, lifespan and simplicity of the
appropriate technology would be a prime concern in considering such
alternatives.
Enhancing
community participation in building, monitoring and maintaining rural water
supply schemes is integral to the success of the RWSS programme. However,
this is constrained by the lack of capacity and a feeble sense of ownership
of the schemes that is further compounded by communal disputes over water
rights. The burdens of cost sharing for communities through labour
contributions are also increasingly felt as development activities increase,
and are exacerbated by the steady migration of young people from villages to
towns.
While
the Royal Government continues its commitment to build water and sanitation
infrastructure in rural institutions such as schools, basic health units and
religious institutions, their coverage level remains lower than the national
average. Attaining universal coverage for institutional water supply will
thus prove a significant challenge.
Supportive Environment
A
royal decree was issued in 1992 that stressed the great importance of access
to and use of safe drinking water and sanitation facilities as an integral
component of sustainable development. This has greatly spurred on the
initiatives to improve the water supply and sanitation situation in the
country.
While
no administrative policies or legislative framework on water supply and
related rights exists as yet, the Bhutan Water Vision, Water Act and Water
Policy are being formulated to create an enabling environment for the
integrated and efficient management of water resources. Processes to develop
a national watershed management strategy are also underway.
In
1997, the first pilot National Baseline Water Survey was conducted to
estimate national water quality standards. Reflecting the growing concerns of
water pollution near urban and industrial centres and mines that were found
in the survey, water monitoring programmes are to be undertaken on a periodic
basis.
Institutionally,
the Public Health Engineering section of the Department of Health now
implements the activities relating to rural water supply. At the community
level, water management committees have been formed and water caretakers
trained to oversee the operation and maintenance of the water schemes. This,
however, has not proved to be very successful, judging by the many schemes
that are poorly maintained and in dilapidated condition, with water quality
monitoring aspects largely ignored.
The
ultimate objective would involve the full transfer of the implementation and
management of the RWSS schemes to the communities themselves, with relevant
technical backstopping and resources. However, this is currently seen as
impractical given the lack of appropriate capacities in communities and the
absence of a legal and policy framework.
Priorities for Development Assistance
Increasing clean & improved
water supply coverage in rural areas through the RWSS programme
Rehabilitating existing water supply schemes
Strengthening community participation & capacity building to plan,
manage & maintain rural water supply infrastructure
Developing & implementing alternative clean water source
technologies
Planning & implementing urban water supply for remaining urban
& satellite towns
Establishing & monitoring water quality standards through surveys
and programmes
Formulating & subsequently implementing the mandate of the Water
Act/Policy.
Monitoring
and Evaluation Environment
|
Elements
Of Monitoring
|
Assessment
|
|
Data
gathering capacities
|
Fair
|
|
Quality
of recent information
|
Fair
|
|
Statistical
tracking capacities
|
Weak
|
|
Statistical
analysis capacities
|
Weak
|
|
Capacity
to incorporate statistical analysis into policy, planning and
resource
allocation mechanisms
|
Fair
|
|
Monitoring
and evaluation
mechanisms
|
Fair
|
LIST OF
ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS
|
AIDS
|
Acquired
immune deficiency syndrome
|
|
BHU
|
Basic
Health Unit
|
|
BTF
|
Bhutan Trust Fund for Environmental Conservation
|
|
CPR
|
Contraceptive
Prevalence Rate
|
|
EFA
|
Education
For All
|
|
EIA
|
Environment
Impact Assessment
|
|
GYT
|
Geog Yargay Tsogchung ( Block
Development Committee)
|
|
HDI
|
Human
Development Index
|
|
HIES
|
Household
Income and Expenditure Survey
|
|
HIV
|
Human
Immunodeficiency Virus
|
|
IDD
|
Iodine
Deficiency Disorder
|
|
IEC
|
Information,
Education and Communication
|
|
IMR
|
Infant
Mortality Rate
|
|
KAP
|
Knowledge,
Attitude, Practice variation KABP with belief
|
|
MCH
|
Maternal
and Child Health
|
|
MDT
|
Millennium
Development Target
|
|
MMR
|
Maternal
Mortality Rate
|
|
MRE
|
Most
Recent Estimate
|
|
M+E
|
Monitoring
and Evaluation
|
|
n.a.
|
Not
available
|
|
NCD
|
Nature
Conservation Division
|
|
NEC
|
National
Environment Commission
|
|
NES
|
National
Environment Strategy
|
|
NHDR
|
National
Human Development Report
|
|
NHS
|
National
Healthy Survey
|
|
NMCP
|
National
Malaria Control Programme
|
|
Nu
|
Ngultrum,
the Bhutanese currency
|
|
NWAB
|
National
Women's Association of Bhutan
|
|
PHES
|
Public
Health Engineering Section
|
|
PEM
|
Protein
Malnutrition
|
|
STD
|
Sexually
Transmitted Diseases
|
|
TB
|
Tuberculosis
|
|
TBA
|
Trained
Birth Attendant
|
|
U5MR
|
Under-Five
Mortality Rate
|
|
RGoB
|
Royal
Government of Bhutan
|
|
RNR
|
Renewable
Natural Resources
|
|
TFR
|
Total
Fertility Rate
|
|
UN
|
United
Nations
|
|
UNDP
|
United
Nations Development Programme
|
|
UNICEF
|
United
Nations Children's Fund
|
|
VHW
|
Village
Health Worker
|
|
WFP
|
World
Food Program
|
|
WHO
|
World
Health Organization
|
|